[RCM.04.05.2009] New European documentary reveals striking contrasts in the Statements of Senior Scottish Investigators and American on the other with regards to criminal evidence in the Lockerbie incident  ?

 

Edinburgh, 24.04.2009 JANA sources - A new documentary on the Lockerbie incident was shown at the seat of the Scottish parliament in Edinburg, Thursday night, the documentary is produced by Dutch production company for the Dutch TV network (VPRO) in collaboration with the German channels (ZDF) and (ARTE).

The film sheds doubt on evidence which accusations were based on, and reveals striking contrasts in statements made by officials who devised these accusations.

The film "Return to Lockerbie" was shown in the presence of a number of Scottish lawmakers, victims' families and correspondents of British and Dutch TV channels and newspapers.

The film primarily focuses on the bomb timer, which was allegedly found at the crash site, and the circumstances that surrounded the handling of the alleged significant piece of evidence.

The new documentary, which is being shown for the first time, revealed contrasts in statements made by senior judiciaries and investigators in Scotland and FBI investigators, on the timer of the bomb on board the Pan Am plane, which was alleged to have been found by Scottish police and FBI during investigations into the Lockerbie incident.

The film revealed that at the time when Scottish chief prosecutor Lord Fraser and head of investigation Stewart Henderson insisted the timer never left British soil. Chief investigator of the American federal bureau of investigation Richard Marquez and the expert who examined the piece Tom Thurman asserted the timer was taken to the U.S. where it was examined.

The film revealed that the person who examined and analyzed the timer at the Federal Bureau of Investigation was a professor of political science Tom Thurman and not an explosives expert.

In this regard, the film highlighted the accusations made by Fredrick White Hurst, Federal Bureau of Investigation forensic expert, against the mentioned professor of political science that he changed his report. And on the significance of the evidence, FBI agent, who headed the American side in the investigation of the incident Marquez, said "He wrote in the report that accusations cannot be based on the piece of the electrical circuit of the timer, let alone a trial".

Following the presentation of the film, audience were surprised by the striking contrasts in statements of Scottish senior judiciaries and police on one hand, and American FBI officials, who supervised the investigations and said they have examined the mentioned piece, on the other.

A member of the Scottish House of Representatives described what she saw as shameful.  "As a former Scottish public prosecutor, I think comments made by the former Scottish public prosecutor in the film, where he expressed some doubts, are shameful," she said. "The former Scottish public prosecutor did not in any way reveal these doubts throughout the past years (…) Matters revealed in the film are extraordinary, contrasts concerning key evidence that was not secure... it's the end of the case."

A research journalist informed the mentioned Scottish parliament member "The film will subject Scottish judicial system under scrutiny".

Dr. Jim Swire, Head of families of victims, expressed anger at the striking contrasts of Scottish and American officials that were revealed in the film.

"There is proof of widespread confusion regarding the timer and who it was handled," Dr. Swire said after witnessing the film. "The impression one comes out with, some people are trying participating in a story where they don't want to reveal facts".

The producers of the documentary said some Scottish parliamentarians, who witnessed the film asked for another presentation so other representatives could see it, especially that last night's presentation coincided with an intensive parliament session, and hence most of the parliamentarians were not able to see the film.

JANA reporter in London quoted viewers of the film as saying the new evidence shown in the film will change the entire course of the case.

The Scottish Court of Criminal Appeal concluded that Abdel Basset Al-Maghrahi could have faced a lapse of justice and ruled he should be granted a new appeal, where the first session is set for 28th of this month in Edinburgh, Scotland. And if proven that a lapse of justice has occurred, as a lot of people think, the consequences would grave on the Scottish judiciary, and could lead to accusations of misleading the course of justice.

Producers of "Return to Lockerbie" documentary said the Dutch TV network (VPRO) and German channels (ZDF) and (ARTE) will broadcast the film on 27th of this month. While British channels will broadcast it later.